Sunday, November 15, 2026

Cost of Living or Cost of Housing?


Chicago, via iconic skyline elements

Recently I've had multiple reasons to visit Chicago from the Quad Cities, a distance of only a few hours (which could be even easier to access if we ever got the train between them). And because I've been there more frequently, I've had a chance to do things I might not do if I had only a few hours or even a few days in the "big city," like, for instance, going to grocery stores and looking at prices, wandering the streets and checking out the big ads for real estate, and similar street-level random activities. And this has me thinking: are the differences in cost of living between the Quad Cities and Chicago really differences in cost of living--the cost of everyday activities and interactions--or just the cost of housing--the entry point to living there at all?

Now, I don't mean (at all!) to suggest that cost of housing is insignificant. Much of the developed world is experiencing a simultaneous and ongoing housing "crisis" (which, much like the so-called "crisis of the humanities" in academia, has long since become so engrained that "crisis" loses all meaning and we should just call it a longterm shortage). Housing expenses are an ever-increasing percentage of family budgets, and the cost and difficulty of obtaining housing is a major factor in where people can and choose to live. 

However.

I suggest that there is a meaningful difference between it costing more to do day-to-day activities and it costing more to have housing. Firstly, a place with high cost of living and low cost of housing would be somewhere that is easy to move into and out of, but hard to stay in, while a place with lower cost of living but high cost of housing has a major barrier to entry but it easier to stay in once you get there--which can cause significant lock-in for those who might have obtained their housing earlier and are now sitting on an appreciating asset and a significant degree of lock-out for those not so situated. Secondly, there is the question of whether salaries responding to inflation (a change in the cost of living) will or will not reflect changes in housing costs: does reducing inflation but still having skyrocketing housing costs (independent of other costs) potentially penalize those who wish to move to or need to rent in expensive areas? Conversely, does adjusting for runaway inflation if housing costs are not keeping up with that inflation potentially allow for better mobility between urban areas?

 I think it is helpful to break down the cost of living somewhere along three axes, on which I want to briefly and summarily compare the QCA to Chicago: the cost of buying things, the cost of getting around, and the cost of having somewhere to live. Or, if you prefer, commerce, transportation, and housing.

1. The Cost of Buying Things (Commerce)

Here we see, I would suggest, some differentiation but not a lot of differentiation between the QCA and Chicago. It costs, say, 8 dollars for a latte in Chicago, and 6 in the QCA: not a tiny difference, especially if you're drinking a lot of coffee. A night out in Chicago might be a similar 25% more than in the Quad Cities, and of course the top line is a lot higher: there are the kinds of Michelin-star restaurants and their ilk in Chicago that could blow the top off any costs to go out that the QCA would ever provide.

But the bottom end is actually much more similar than it might appear. Walk into an ALDI in Chicago and the prices are identical in most cases to the same store in Rock Island or Davenport. Go to a McDonald's and (while substantially higher than they were pre-pandemic) the prices are again more or less the same. You can spend a lot more in Chicago than you can in the QCA if you want. But you can also spend a little more, or even basically nothing more. The range is substantially wider in Chicago, but the baseline cost of buying many things in Chicago is not actually higher than the QCA: it's just that there are more expensive options available.

2. The Cost of Getting Around (Transportation)

Of course, getting to buy those things is quite different in the two metro areas. The cost of car ownership is likely higher in Chicago--insurance is certainly higher, gas is similar to the Illinois side of the QCA but without the option of going to lower-cost Iowa for it, and parking tickets are both more expensive and more frequent--and the frustration of driving in the city is legendary.

However, Chicago has two major amenities that the QCA larger does not have: walkable streets and serious public transportation.

The link above suggests it costs about $2000 a year to get car insurance in the Quad Cities, a full thousand or even more less than Chicago. However, a Chicago CTA unlimited pass is $75 a month; 12 of those is $900 a year. If you can replace a car with public transportation, in other words, you save just about as much as the Chicago extra cost of car insurance is, meaning going from 2 cars to 1 makes the cost a wash (of course, ignoring the additional costs associated with a car). And data suggests that this is indeed the case: households in the QCA have about 2 cars, and those in Chicago average 1 car.

And that's assuming you use the CTA often enough to need a monthly pass: if you can walk, bike, or otherwise avoid using either a car or transit, you can of course save more.

3. The Cost of Having Somewhere to Live (Housing) 

Now, here we firmly diverge. 

Zillow has the average rent in Davenport as about a thousand a month cheaper than in Chicago. That's per month--the transportation costs, notably, were about the same difference per year. As noted above, housing is a huge percentage of the household budget here. The same source has average Chicago values for homes about $140,000 higher than Davenport. I use Davenport here because most data that's easily available disagreggates the QCA; Davenport is much less expensive than Bettendorf (which is around as high as Chicago, for house prices actually, though not rent) but a bit more than Moline or Rock Island, and thus felt like a reasonable medium point for the area.

This is why I suggest that the cost of living differential between these cities is fundamentally one of housing price. If you were gifted a home or won a small lottery to buy one in Chicago, you could keep your income similar to what it is in the Quad Cities and do OK (though note that with current mortgage rates, you'd really need to buy it, not just finance it, for that to hold true). You might shop at a bargain grocery store or drink fewer lattes (that standard canard of lecturing to millennials and Gen Z), but it would be doable.

What would not be doable on a QCA salary in Chicago would be the housing costs from renting or a mortgage (especially at 7+%). 

None of this means it is cheap to live in Chicago. But it does suggest that the root of the difference is fundamentally housing stock: if we reduced the price of housing in Chicago, it would look a lot more like the QCA in terms of affordability--and I think generally* that would be a good thing.

If you're wondering why this has the "15 minute city" tag it's because this is, to me, the key to the 15 minute city concept: a city that is easy to get around and has a lot of different options for what you buy and where (and therefore price levels) can be very livable--as long as we also have places to live within 15 minutes of all that stuff.

* Offer does not apply if you already own a house in Chicago and this would lower the value of your asset. 

Wednesday, November 11, 2026

Why Aesthetics Do Sadly Matter

So I'll start by saying that my default orientation is that when we spend money on urbanist issues, the money should go to doing as much as possible: more bike lane, more transit, more parks, etc.

Thus my default would be to say that spending that same money to make things pretty is a waste: that decoration could be used to have another few miles of track, or another exit on a station, or something.

But I have had to grapple with the fact that this is fundamentally short-sighted, and indeed counterproductive, for the following reasons:

1. People Gotta Feel Comfortable Using It

This is really all the reasons rolled into one, if you interpret it correctly, but for these purposes I'll define it a bit more narrowly than that: people need to want to use the service, system, or project, and to not be repeled by its appearance either aesthetically or in terms of cleanliness or repair.

Look at this ramp in Chicago. It's technically perfectly functional, but it is very worn, and doesn't induce people to use it. It looks janky. And while I obviously still walked up and down it, it's not exactly a comfortable experience.

Or take this Davenport bike rack, which doesn't inspire confidence either: it's not actually anchored to the ground anymore!

Now, these are examples that are about wear and tear or damage: they could fit my utilitarian preferences set up above too. But they stand in for a larger point: that which looks less impressive than it should be will get less of a positive response than it should. Aesthetics can make people want to or not want to use something, and we need them to use it.

2. People Need to Feel Safe

A major element in feeling comfortable is feeling safe: bare concrete, minimalist metal, and other simple and cheap solutions can make people feel unsafe.

Standing in the Ground Transportation Center in Davenport does not always inspire one with confidence, inside or out.

And while I don't mind graffiti much, for some people waiting for that bus by that graffiti will mean they feel unsafe and don't want to wait there--and may not use it at all.

3. People Need to Be Invited

For this section, let me use positive examples.

The classic appearance of the Metro signs in Paris is presumably more expensive than a sign in Helvetica on blank white. Certainly the process of designing and commissioning it was, even if the marginal price of the sign itself is not. But it makes the metro seem like a more inviting and interesting place, inducing people to want to use it.

Likewise, the public art around Gare du Nord gives a sense of a place that you want to be.

Making people feel not just that a space can function for them, but that they want to be involved in it, want to be there, want to use it, is a positive good.

So even if I don't like spending money on making things look nice, rather than just functional -- it's actually pretty important (and as usual, I should get over myself).

Sunday, November 8, 2026

Getting Around: Chicago

 Chicago is a lovely city. One of my favorites. I spent many happy years there, and also I go back periodically. So today I want to talk about Chicago as a transit city, much like I did London and Paris. How do you get around? What are the options? And how much do I enjoy it (spoiler: a lot).

1. The Bus

The workhorse of the Chicago transit system is, unsurprisingly both in a global and in a US context, the bus.


The Chicago Transit Authority (CTA) is the primary transit agency in the city, and it operates a lot of buses. Some of them are workhorses like the articulated vehicles above and below:

Others are more modest sizes, but I don't like those as much so I'm not going to show a picture of one.

They run local and express, they criss-cross the city, and fundamentally they are the backbone of how you get around Chicago. If you are taking the CTA, and you aren't going to a particularly iconic or significant spot, you're probably starting or ending your journey (or both!) on a bus.

It's notable that Chicago has recently been improving the experience of bus-riding, especially downtown, where there are now much more fully recognizable stations rather than just signed stops for the bus.


This also comes, as you can see in the picture, with red bus-only lanes, which make the bus experience downtown not as entirely excruciating as it used to be.

2. The L

Of course, the bus is vital, but it's not iconic, or distinctive (many places have buses and the Chicago buses are very similar to buses run in other cities).

The L (sometimes styled El), however, is.

Now, the Loop (the elevated track seen above) is the most iconic version of the L, and the reason it gets that "elevated" name.


And the elevated sections are significant both in terms of the advantages of elevated rail and the amount of the city they cover in addition to the Loop.

Just a great section of train line, in general, is the L.

But it also goes underground, on the Blue and Red lines through the city center.


The infamous Jackson tunnel (between the Red and Blue) stinks to high heaven, but it does also make transfers very easy.

Still, even with the underground sections, you're probably thinking above the street if you're thinking of the Chicago "subway" that we call the L.


And for good reason.

3. The Metra

But the L is not the only major rail in Chicago; it runs in concert with a commuter rail line (and "commuter" is definitely the right word, not regional rail) called the Metra.


The Metra does do pickups and dropoffs within the city, even though it's oriented for commuters from outside of it; it's just the timings that are bad, not the stops.


OK, some of the stops are pretty minimalist too.

Ironically, despite not being the "L," much of the Metra is elevated as well; it's just Chicago's favorite way to incorporate the train into the cityscape.


Pictured: a Metra overpass.

4 & 5. Amtrak and Greyhound

I would not recommend Amtrak trains as the main way to move about Chicago. But Chicago is more than Chicago, if you know what I mean, and for some points in Chicagoland, Amtrak is technically viable: it connects to mostly other cities (some effectively, like Milwaukee; some less so, like anywhere further than St. Louis) but some of those "other cities" are suburbs like Napierville or Aurora. 


(This is a Metra train, but it is running on the same track).

The same is true of Greyhound (below).


Both of these are mostly intercity transit, but deserve being mentioned because Chicagoland is legitimately big enough to incorporate such transit into itself (though not nearly as effectively as either Paris or especially London do).

6. Other Buses

Did you think we were done with buses? The more fool you! Pace, the other main transit agency in Chicagoland, also runs buses around the metro area.

Pace buses actually penetrate deep into Chicagoland, and provide substantially more frequent transit in some of the suburbs than one might expect given their size.

Pace also connects frequently with the CTA and Metra to create something of an integrated corridor.

So that's how you get around Chicago: mostly on CTA buses and trains, but also on the Metra, Amtrak, Greyhound, and Pace. 

Wednesday, November 4, 2026

The Pleasure of Finding Bikes in the Wild

One of the things I've realized I do when I'm in a new city, or a new part of a city, or back in a part of a city I haven't been in in a while, is that I take pictures of bikes.


Above: Toronto. But it doesn't really matter, because I do it everywhere.

Why do I do it? Because I think that bikes, especially the kind of cargo ebikes I tend to love taking phoots of, like that one, but really any kind of frequent visibility of bikes, are an indicator species of a kind of effective urbanism that I quite like.

In other words, where there are bikes being used, parked, and ridden in an area, that's an indication that something good is going on there in terms of the area's desirability (someone wanted to bike there), accessibility by non-car means (someone biked there), and what it normalizes (someone biked there, left their bike, and it is visible where others can see it) that I like.

1. Someone Wanted to Bike There


This line of bikes in Montréal indicates that this is a place people want to be, and that they wanted to bike there. Now, bikes are cheap, and sometimes that means people use them because they have no other option. But given the car-dependent nature of most Western cities, a beater car is not that expensive as an initial investment, and much more practical--so someone still had to want to use a bike for this (after all, foot is free).

Seeing bikes somewhere is a good sign that it's an area people want to be in, and that it's close enough either to other areas people want to be in (that they'd already biked to) or where people actually live (because the bike has limited range in practice) to justify the bike as a mode.

2. Someone Biked There

Relatedly, the presence of the bike means other bikes could come there too: a bike is a potential mode here, unlike on a highway median or something.


The more casually it's left here, as above in Seattle, the more likely you are to see other bikes and to think of the bike as normal (I include "huge racks of bikes ala Amsterdam" as casual, because when there are that many racks, it becomes casual to have one).


No one who parked here had to think about it a lot and mull the options.

3. The Bike Is Normal

And that, ultimately, is what I think the presence of these bikes that I photograph means to me. The bike is normal, or at least normalizing; people besides me are also using it.


I'm not the only one riding a bike to the grocery store!


Sometimes the grocery store takes the bike to you.

But either way, seeing these bikes is an indication that, well, there are bikes. And that might be ultimately tautological, but it's also important: seeing bikes means more people see bikes, and the cycle hopefully continues in the positive direction.

And that is why I love taking photos of bikes.

Also, I think they look cool.

Sunday, November 1, 2026

Free Transit on Election Day in the QCA

Free transit may not be a great strategy for a transit agency long-term, but it's definitely a good thing to let people get where they need to go on important days.

Election day is just such a day. So I'm glad that the QCA transit agencies are all offering free rides on that day.

It's a very good thing that anyone can get to the polls--to the extent, of course, that any transit serves their polling place.

And if someone is going to go, the less that gets in their way the better, which is why I think it's also good that they're not requiring people to show proof that they're going to vote. Instead, it's just all rides that are free, which should make it easier for everyone.

Good on you, CitiBus and Metro. Good work.

And now it behooves us all to get out and vote. 

Wednesday, October 28, 2026

Making Biking Livable

How do we make biking liveable? By this I don't just mean, how do we make biking pleasant, enjoyable, a part of everyday life that's embraced (as we might mean by liveable cities or a liveable neighborhood). I also mean: how do we make it survivable given the current car dominance of American cities?

I ask because everywhere I go in the US it seems like bike infrastructure outside of the absolute largest cities is basically out to kill its users.

1. The Edges Aren't Options

Here's a fun question: where should I bike here:


Now, I approached this as a pedestrian, so unless you're in the UK it looks like the wrong side of the street. But ignore that; assume I biked back the other way. Where am I to go?

Lots of automotive users will tell me to bike on the sidewalk. That's obviously not an option here. Neither is where I'm actually supposed to bike, on the edge of the shared road. I could bike around the car, and I certainly would, but the whole reason the car is parked on the sidewalk is that there's not really supposed to be parking here at all, and so biking around pushes me out into the middle of the street, where the cars really don't want me either.

How about here?

This is a normal street. No car is parked oddly. But it's also a fast road, and the only way through this area without zigging and zagging a million times. But the only options for biking on it would be the side of a road where cars are zipping past over 40 mph, that is to say 2-3x my speed, or on the sidewalk which is both illegal and not designed for wheels (a conversation for wheelchair users as well of course).

We need to stop pretending that just putting bikes on the edge of the road is giving them space of functionally incorporating them into the city.

2. Don't Squeeze Pedestrians

The reasons I shouldn't bike on the sidewalk begin with the law, but there's reason behind that law--and not just the way sidewalks are often built out of slabs that don't lend themselves well to riding. 

One of them is this: the width of paths designed for pedestrians and only technically incorporating bikes. Yes, the Mississippi River path is gorgeous, and it's underutilized so a bike usually has no problem. But actually passing a pedestrian, or a group of them, here is a bear. And that makes sense: people on foot take a lot less space to safely negotiate their way around each other than people on bikes, due to things like speed and reaction time, and the paths were built with either just pedestrians or pedestrians and very slow bikes in mind. 

Sidewalks for natural reasons do even more of this, and have cars on one side as an added danger.

But now we have both e-bikes increasing speeds and the kind of spandex/road bike combinations that passed me on the Duck Creek Trail last week (no shade, it was impressive! But it's also a lot faster than the trail was designed for).

Now, a wider and better engineered path can work for this; I'm not against shared paths! But all too often if we get bikes out of the gutters on the streets, we just shove them into pedestrian spaces without redesign or accommodation.

3. Plan for Biking 

What this boils down to is that we need to actually plan for biking not as a behavior that we can't eradicate and thus must grudgingly give something to, but as an actual mode of transportation and movement. 

That means space given to bikes independent of the car and the foot traffic. It can share space, if the space is engineered to be shared, like this slightly wider path on the other side of the Mississippi:

But it shouldn't be simply putting bikes where others go and hoping it works out.

That's why spaces that actually acknowledge the bike formally are generally preferable.

Note that there's actually not much if any more space for the bike here than in the trails above; what's been done is to visibly and tactiley separate the bike space, and thus make it so that no road users need to accommodate each other without help from the road design.

I used Boston above, to emphasize this is doable in the US, but of course there's European examples as well, like the classic Dutch street:

The cities may be larger than, say, the Quad Cities, but the streets aren't; do we really think Brady and Harrison, all four car lanes each way, get more traffic than downtown Amsterdam or Boston? 

And if they do, isn't that actually a bigger indictment of how we've organized these much smaller cities around the car?

Biking can be liveable--can be survivable--but only if we actually design streets to make it so.

Sunday, October 25, 2026

Stations That Don't Suck

How do we design stations that don't suck?

All too often, the stations on US public transit, well, suck.

Either they're far too overbuilt, leading to high costs, project overruns, and visibly unused station areas, or they're completely minimal to the point of nonexistence, or they're just plain inefficient and ineffective.

So how do we make stations that don't suck?

Well, of course, some good advice might come from the rest of the world--and from our own past practice.

1. Label Clearly

Whether you build a giant palace to the train or a simple hovel by the side of the tracks, making sure people can actually find their trains or buses is important.


There are two different signs here that identify this as track 32, and there's clear signage of what is at track 32. Now, I'm not going to say Paris Gare du Nord does everything right (the numbering of tracks can be confusing when they're in different train halls within the overall complex) but this is solid. 


I'm already on the record as a fan of Montréal's REM, but the ability to find where the train doors are coming and how full each car is makes a pretty strong combination--not to mention that system map that's right next to those indicators, making sure you understand where this particular train is within the larger REM network.


The Montréal Metro also has some nice labeling here, as they tell you where to go on the floor, not just on the wall.

2. Provide (the Right Kind of) Space

A good station has space for people and things, but it doesn't fall into either of the two most common pitfalls I see in US: way too much space for the service demand or nowhere to actually sit down.


Toronto does fall a little bit into this on the Eglinton Crosstown, but at least the labeling helps you understand that this part of the waiting are won't actually receive a train.


Chicago's Union Station has a very impressive hall, but it's quite far from the trains--and that means that while you can sit here, you then have to hustle your bustle to actually get on something. 


And that's not even getting into the weird combination of overbuilt and underbuilt at the more rural Amtrak stations, where you simultaneously have a small built footprint (just a tiny stationhouse and a little covering for waiting passengers outside) and a huge area you have to walk across to get on the train itself.


Contrast that with the similarly minimalist train station at Noisy-le-Sec, and you see a station that is actually designed for people to wait near where the train stops and move the train on again quickly.

Yes, the intercity rail patterns are very different, and that contributes to the difference in experience--but it also is a matter of design. American stations frequently centralize waiting areas and then don't really have much in the way of a platform-side space, which makes for awkward bunching and crowding followed by an unpleasant experience if the train is late (which they often are).

3. Minimalism in the Right Places

Here let me complement a US metro system: the DC Metro gets this one right.


This station is basically just a platform inside a tunnel. It's minimalist. But the minimalism is used effectively: the decoration here is just lines and arcs, and yet it creates a sense of visual expanse and consistency that transforms the space from boring to impressive. 



Not all WMATA stations have that effect, of course--the aboveground stations are just as prone to ugliness and lack of seating (notice the lean in the foreground) as anywhere else--but the underground stations are a triumph of not overbuilding to make something impressive, while not forgetting that a station can and should look cool.

This is how I feel about things like the tiling in Jean-Talon in Montréal. 


If the station is going to have tiling anyway, it's not that much different to make it patterned, colored tile. But it adds a lot to the station. So it's minimalist in the sense that it doesn't involve a massive art installation (not that those are terrible, but they're certainly not necessary the way "tile on the floor" is) but it's using that to still improve the station appearance--and in this case also the wayfinding and directing of traffic.

So how do we build a station that doesn't suck? We make sure people can get around it, we make sure that the space they're getting around in isn't too inefficient or unpleasant, and we keep the design simple without sacrificing some level of distinctive attractiveness.

How are the stations around you? 

Cost of Living or Cost of Housing?

Chicago, via iconic skyline elements Recently I've had multiple reasons to visit Chicago from the Quad Cities, a distance of only a few ...