CityBracket 2025, Round 3, Matchup 2 (Semifinal 2): Vancouver, BC vs. Washington, DC

On this side of the bracket, two of my favorite cities to visit have emerged victorious: Vancouver surprisingly besting both Toronto and New York on the bracket of pure tourism and Washington, DC coming out much less surprisingly from what may have been the easiest bracket, given my family's tendency to live in less urbanist cities.

Let's see who gets to go up against the European giant in the final! Will it be a battle of national capitals, or will the US be excluded entirely?

Category 1: Visiting Without A Car

a) How can you get to the city? 

Both cities sit at the end of an Amtrak corridor that is the primary train option, have fairly robust intercity bus/coach service, and connected their airports to their subway lines.

Unfortunately for Vancouver, DC has two airports, both on the Metro, and the Acela corridor is a stronger rail link than Amtrak Cascades or anything VIA Rail currently offers.

The SeaBus is a personal favorite (and I love that building), and BC Ferries is nice, but they can't tip the scales against that.

VERDICT: Vancouver 0, DC 1

b) How do you get around?

The Washington Metro is a nice system, and DC is a very walkable area in general. Tourists have no problem getting around the city.

SkyTrain is also pretty straightforward, and Vancouver downtown is just as walkable. 

Ultimately, I think the visitor-oriented parts of Vancouver are more compact, and SkyTrain is a simpler system to navigate.

Price is also a concern--except the costs of their transit systems to ride are pretty much parallel. But note that Vancouver works on a zone system, while DC is distance-based--this means that again, it's just easier to get around on the TransLink system.

VERDICT: Vancouver 1, DC 1

c) What are the limits on a visitor without a car?

On the one hand, it's pretty easy to get everywhere a tourist might be interested in in both cities.

Everyone's Chinatown is easy to get to.

But overall, here I think DC really shines: UBC is on a good bus line and going to be on SkyTrain, but pretty much everything in DC that a tourist needs is right there on Metro.

This meerkat, however, might disagree, since he's kinda stuck in the zoo.

VERDICT: Vancouver 1, DC 2 (unless you're a meerkat)

Category 2: Living Without A Car

a) Can you expect to get to work?

In DC, about 2/3 of commuters use non-auto modes for their commute, compared to a bit over half in Vancouver.  That's not quite as true for the overall metro area, though, which flips the percentage around in DC, and by a little bit it's even worse in Vancouver.

Basically, the answer is yes, but you'll want to live in the main city--and there, DC wins.

VERDICT: Vancouver 1, DC 3

b) Can you live the rest of your life?

Overall, about half of metro Vancouver trips are by transit or active modes. That is not the case in DC; commutes are heavily out of the car, but that does not appear to translate to the rest of life (at least, not in the wider metro area; DC residents may be another matter).

This is reflected in car ownership. Metro DC is at 1.67 cars per capita, and no single part of the Vancouver metro, let alone the overall, is that high.

VERDICT: Vancouver 2, DC 3

c) How are the basic amenities?

I love Vancouver's amenities (witness how I gave it this category last time against NYC). But DC has it all: the Smithsonian (even if they cave to presidential pressure), walkable streets, gorgeous architecture.

VERDICT: Vancouver 2, DC 4

Category 3: Miscellaneous

a) Are there people on the street?

Yes, in both cases. In my experience outside the most downtowny parts of the city, though, DC has fewer eyes on the street than Vancouver. 

That's a subjective measure, of course. There's people here, even if I tend to avoid taking pictures of too many strangers:

Just like there are in this random Vancouver park:

But I can't help my subjective reading--and that is, Vancouver has this more.

VERDICT: Vancouver 3, DC 4

b) Where is the city's urbanism going?

This is a place where DC is doing well--just extended Metro, has plans for more--but Vancouver is just doing better, with the BC upzone, SkyTrain extensions, and the lack of a federal government that wants to take over the city and undo its work.

VERDICT: Vancouver 4, DC 4

c) Is it functionally diverse?

DC and Vancouver are both highly diverse cities, although DC metro is likely more segregated by race, especially given the city/suburb divide. Canada just tends towards lower segregation, even if it's still a potential issue. As is often the case with US cities, racial diversity in DC is more about a Black/White divide, where the city is plurality Black and the metro area is not, whereas there is much more Asian population in Vancouver.

Again, both highly diverse--but I think this goes to Vancouver.

VERDICT: Vancouver 5, DC 4

d) How do people there react to knowing you're not using a car?

I don't think either city would treat that as odd (which is a theme this late in the bracket) but there are still noticeable differences. It really depends whether you were in the inner city, in which case I think DC is less concerned about you than Vancouver is, or in the outer suburbs, where DC residents will actually start looking at you oddly (as US people do on this topic).

But in the land of fine distinctions, I think that matters.

VERDICT: Vancouver 6, DC 4

e) How do people react to people living close together?

DC is a dense city overall, but it has a lot more mid-level and low density, especially in the suburbs. Vancouver has its Vancouverism, pushing people close together even with a visual streetscape that's lower-density-looking. In neither city would you be thought of as odd for being in a dense area, but it's more central to Vancouver culture than DC

North Vancouver is still pretty dense. 

Of course, so is random urban DC:

But the overall population is denser in Vancouver: the metro area by about 3 times compared to the entire DC metro, while the cities themselves are closer but Vancouver is still a bit denser. 

FINAL VERDICT: Vancouver 7, DC 4

Well, this was a much closer matchup, but Vancouver has seen off the last US city in the competition. Next up: the final, a matchup of two of my absolute favorite cities (no surprise there) and the best of Canada against the best of the UK. May the best Commonwealth city win!